Tuesday, April 6, 2010
Stereotypes in Maus
Let me start off by saying my post is not meant to be offensive. Yet, one thing that really struck me in the first part we had to read is the number of stereotypes the author used in describing his father, and what seems to be his deliberate use of them. Many of these stereotypes also happen to deal with money and thriftiness, something that people often associate with those of Jewish ethnicity. One prime example of this can be found at the beginning of chapter 3 when the author comes in with a new tape recorder and his father laments on how he could of got if for no more than half the price at Korvettes, which kind of pertubes the author. (pg. 73). Also, another example is shown later on page 77 when his father only gives half of what he makes on the black market to the family because he sees it necessary to save half. This kind of gives an explanation for his father's thriftiness and tightness for money when he is always saying money doesn't grow on trees. Yet, this brings me to a questions. What is the purpose of these stereotypes? There seems to be many answers. One being they are meant to kind of poke fun, try to lighten up the atmosphere of such a dark subject, as some of the stereotypical descriptions are a little comical. Another legitimate possibility is that the stereotypes are used just to characterize his father, because being from the war generation he is probably quite thrifty, and help explain the affects of his holocaust experience. What are your guys thoughts on these stereotypical descriptions found throughout the reading, did you notice them, are they comical, meaningful, or something else? I feel that the book will go on to explain and sort of justify many of the characteristics of the father that the author, his son, dislikes using the telling of his father's holocaust experience.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
axel-
ReplyDeletei agree with you! I too noticed the underlying stereotypes throughout the selection. I believe, however, that the author decided to include them in the work to further emphasize the distance and hostility felt between him and his father. we already noted the odd scene where he blatantly lied to his father by telling us, the readers,some of his personal stories.
I also believe that it is necessary for the author to include these connotations for purpose of character development. because of these little insights added by the author about his father's eccentric behavior we can now derive a difference between his actions and behaviors in his early years and those of his twilight. it kind of shows how different attributes of one's personality tend to intensify as one grows older and more set in one's ways.
I do agree with you but I did not so much notice them on my own when I read it. I feel that these stereotypes were included in the story to further characterize Art's father and show effects of his experience in The Holocaust. This is not the only reason I feel they were included...I feel that they were also included to re-emphasize the difference between Art and his father and maybe this difference is a factor to them not having the best father-son relationship.
ReplyDeleteIf I were to make a claim on the stereotypes used, I would say they were actual legitimate claims characterizing Artie's father. It just may be stereotypical but he did live through the holocaust that would justify his thriftiness. It would be people likes Artie's father that help form those Jewish stereotypes.
ReplyDeleteOn Stereotypes in Maus -
ReplyDeleteabout the character of Artie's
father throughout the volume I of the comic
book titled Maus:
The mention of legitimate possible
explainations for the purpose of the
character, Artie's father, being "thrifty"
is very notable.
(description)
I agree that in the portrayal of Artie's
father in volume I of Maus the author did
use stereotypes. It seems to implicate the
importance of one's own personal experiences,
lifestyle, and environment, as impacts on
character as a result of the past.
This subject would have been great for,
Artie's father, as a memoir because
connecting aspects of a personal history
or a previous time period in one's own past
seems to be within the definition of a memoir.
If Artie's father had written a memoir on
realities of his past, he might have included
some of his personal opinions on how he
thought those character attributes developed
within his personality over time or if he even
saw himself that way at all.
If these stereotypes were factual
( from actual friends and family; or from
defending his character portrayal in this
comic book)
then the stereotypes are something that might
have been a narrated expression and reaction
in memoir if only for their
existence; however, not for the exaggeration
of the author's portrayal of his
father's "thrifty" quality.
(the word purpose)
One can speculate "purpose" mentioned of his
father's perceived stereotyped "thrifty"
character in the comic book. I do agree that
the father is portrayed as being very
financially aware whenever the subject was
appropriate or necessary. Maybe the author's
reasons for this portrayal will unfold more
within the story line of volume II of Maus.